Unpacking the vicious cycle of climate change and digital security

Greater understanding of the interdependent relationship between climate change and the connected world is needed if we are to combat this existential threat
Main Top Image
Image created using Dall-E 2 and Chat GPT-4o

Climate change has a tangible and highly visible impact on the digital world through the damage it causes to the infrastructure underpinning technology. The internet is supported by a vast and diverse array of physical infrastructure, ranging from power stations and networking cables to internet exchange points and data centres. The physicality of this infrastructure makes it inherently vulnerable to the effects of climate change. 

For example, extreme rainfall and rising sea levels drive increased flooding, presenting an operational risk for infrastructure like data centres and power generation components. They also threaten to flood subsea cable landing stations or disrupt seafloor integrity. Storms consistently damage key internet infrastructure: in 2012, Hurricane Sandy cut eleven out of twelve high-capacity transatlantic cables, while recent hurricanes in the US caused mobile network outages after cutting fibre optic cables and damaging cellular towers. 

More intense and frequent wildfires exacerbated by global warming have similar effects, damaging fibre optic cables and cell towers. Ongoing heatwaves and droughts also threaten particularly energy-intensive components: two data centres suffered operational failure for several hours following a major UK heatwave in 2022. Redundancy in the system minimised the direct impact of this particular event, but more frequent and more intense heatwaves spanning the globe raise the spectre of simultaneous failures across data centre networks. 

Data centres themselves exacerbate droughts and water supply issues, raising an interesting point: the relationship between climate change and digital infrastructure is not a one-way road. Just as climate change threatens digital infrastructure, our digital world and dependence on it is in itself a significant driver of climate change. 

Resource consumption drives climate change

One of the major contributors to climate change is energy use and associated fossil fuel consumption. The digital world is a significant part of this: estimates vary but suggest the internet could use 20% of the global electricity supply and emit 5.5% of global carbon emissions by 2025. Some components, like data centres, are particularly energy hungry, and there are suspicions that energy consumption from this sector is even higher than we are led to believe. 

Technosocial developments like the move to cloud computing and the development of AI have increased energy usage and subsequent emissions. AI – and generative AI in particular – requires around 33 times more energy to complete a task than standard software, while some sources suggest global cloud computing emissions exceed those generated by commercial aviation. 

The internet is also a voracious consumer of other natural resources. The physical infrastructure underpinning both the internet and the devices we use to access it does not just appear out of nowhere. Much of the technology underpinning the internet – including end-user devices – is dependent on rare earth elements (REEs) like copper, lithium, or rarer metals like indium and tantalum

This dependence makes REEs highly desirable and the subject of intense geopolitical competition. Our focus on technological progress could see a 10- to 20-fold increase in demand for REEs by 2050. Mining, extracting, and processing REEs cause ecological devastation and produce large amounts of toxic waste, in turn contributing to climate change. 

Disposal of ‘e-waste’ is also a growing issue: much of the approximately 50,000 tonnes of e-waste produced globally each year is landfilled or incinerated, contributing to environmental pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.

Even our efforts to find more sustainable solutions or mitigate the vulnerability of digital infrastructure can create or exacerbate problems, inadvertently contributing to the vicious circle connecting climate change and digital risk. 

For example, the use of satellites to connect to the internet seemingly counters the physical impact of climate change events (or the impact of human activity like conflict) and should ensure connectivity and continuity. However, satellite launches and re-entries damage the ozone layer. 

Decreasing atmospheric density also extends the lifetime of space debris, threatening the physical integrity of satellites and demonstrating that the effects of climate change extend beyond just the surface of our planet. 

Technosocial structures drive climate disinformation

There is a further argument to be made that our behaviour online and the technological structures that facilitate and shape our online interactions are additional contributors to the climate crisis. 

Climate change has long been the subject of mis- and disinformation, but the onset of technosocial platforms of communication like social media, and their predisposition to encourage the spread of disinformation, have undoubtedly exacerbated this trend. 

Politically motivated actors are also increasingly leveraging climate change to achieve political outcomes. This is evidenced by the recent use of the 2025 Los Angeles wildfires to denigrate diversity and equality programmes and climate science deniers campaigning against environmental policies. Disinformation encourages people and decisionmakers to downplay the severity of climate change and its future impacts, with some even coming to the extreme view that climate change is not real. 

These viewpoints and the politicisation of climate change not only drive global lethargy on devising and enacting collaborative and impactful climate action, but also contribute to the election of leaders seeking to enact actively harmful climate policies, further adding to the urgency and severity of the wider issue.  

Disrupting the cycle

Efforts to mitigate the impact of climate-induced events like bolstering resilience, introducing redundancy, and ensuring suitable alternatives if one component fails, will provide short-term protection to the digital ecosystem and its supporting infrastructure. However, they will fail to fundamentally disrupt the continually reinforcing cycle between the digital world and climate change. 

As the climate crisis worsens and the current political climate adds even more complexity to the operating environment, communities instead need to better understand this relationship and take a more future-looking approach. 

Potential courses of action include accelerating the slow shift towards renewable energy sources and diversifying these sources to protect against issues like drought or unpredictable weather. 

Economic incentives already push companies to improve the efficiency of components like data centres, and promising initiatives have started to use excess heat from data centres to warm homes or water supplies. These localised projects could be adapted and promoted across companies and local governments. 

Developments like universal ports, legislation protecting right-to-repair, and lawsuits against tech companies throttling devices to promote new purchases are positive developments in combatting ‘throwaway’ culture and tackling e-waste, even if their effects may be geographically limited. 

Final thoughts

Climate change presents an existential and long-term threat to the future of the digital world and the human industries, activities, and connections ultimately dependent on it. As well as threatening the integrity of physical internet infrastructure, the interactive and self-reinforcing nature of the relationship between climate change and the digital world adds a layer of complexity to an existential issue. 

Solutions need to focus not just on building short-term resilience but also on enacting policies and practices to actively disrupt this feedback loop, protecting both the digital and natural worlds upon which we depend.

Terms and Conditions for the AI-Cybersecurity Essay Prize Competition

Introduction

The AI-Cybersecurity Essay Prize Competition (the “Competition”) is organized by Virtual Routes (“Virtual Routes”) in partnership with the Munich Security Conference (“MSC”). It is sponsored by Google (the “Sponsor”). By entering the Competition, participants agree to these Terms and Conditions (T&Cs).

Eligibility

The Competition is open to individuals worldwide who are experts in the fields of cybersecurity and artificial intelligence (“AI”). Participants must ensure that their participation complies with local laws and regulations.

Submission Guidelines

Essays must address the question: “How will Artificial Intelligence change cybersecurity, and what are the implications for Europe? Discuss potential strategies that policymakers can adopt to navigate these changes.”

Submissions must be original, unpublished works between 800-1200 words, excluding footnotes but including hyperlinks for references.

Essays must be submitted by 2 January 2025, 00:00 am CET., through the official submission portal provided by Virtual Routes.

Only single-authored essays are accepted. Co-authored submissions will not be considered.

Participants are responsible for ensuring their submissions do not infringe upon the intellectual property rights of third parties.

Judging and Awards

Essays will be judged based on insightfulness, relevance, originality, clarity, and evidence by a review board comprising distinguished figures from academia, industry, and government.

The decision of the review board is final and binding in all matters related to the Competition.

Prizes are as follows: 1st Place: €10,000; Runner-Up: €5,000; 3rd Place: €2,500; 4th-5th Places: €1,000 each. The winner will also be invited to attend The Munich Security Conference

Intellectual Property Rights

The author retains ownership of the submitted essay.

By submitting the essay, the author grants Virtual Routes exclusive, royalty-free rights to use, reproduce, publish, distribute, and display the essay for purposes related to the Competition, including but not limited to educational, promotional, and research-related activities.

The author represents, warrants, and agrees that no essay submitted as part of the essay prize competition violates or infringes upon the rights of any third party, including copyright, trademark, privacy, publicity, or other personal or proprietary rights, breaches, or conflicts with any obligation, such as a confidentiality obligation, or contains libellous, defamatory, or otherwise unlawful material.

The author agrees that the organizers can use your name (or your pseudonym) and an image of you in association with your essay for purposes of publicity, promotion and any other activity related to the exercise of its rights under these Terms.

The organizers may remove any essay-related content from its platforms at any time and without explanation.

The organizers may block contributions from particular email or IP addresses without notice or explanation.

The organizers may enable advertising on its platforms and associated social media accounts, including in connection with the display of your essay. The organizers may also use your Material to promote its products and services.

The organizers may, at its sole discretion, categorise Material, whether by means of ranking according to popularity or by any other criteria.

Data Protection

Personal information collected in connection with the Competition will be processed in accordance with Virtual Routes’ Privacy Policy. Participants agree to the collection, processing, and storage of their personal data for the purposes of the Competition.

Liability and Indemnity

Virtual Routes, MSC, and the Sponsor will not be liable for any damages arising from participation in the Competition, except where prohibited by law.

Participants agree to indemnify Virtual Routes, MSC, and the Sponsor against any claims, damages, or losses resulting from a breach of these T&Cs.

General Conditions

Virtual Routes reserves the right to cancel, suspend, or modify the Competition or these T&Cs if fraud, technical failures, or any other factor beyond Virtual Routes’ reasonable control impairs the integrity or proper functioning of the Competition, as determined by Virtual Routes in its sole discretion.

Any attempt by any person to deliberately undermine the legitimate operation of the Competition may be a violation of criminal and civil law, and, should such an attempt be made, Virtual Routes reserves the right to seek damages from any such person to the fullest extent permitted by law.

Governing Law

These Terms and Conditions are governed by the laws of the United Kingdom, without regard to its conflict of law principles. Any dispute arising out of or in connection with these Terms and Conditions, including any question regarding its existence, validity, or termination, shall be referred to and finally resolved by the courts of the United Kingdom. The participants agree to submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts located in the United Kingdom for the resolution of all disputes arising from or related to these Terms and Conditions or the Competition.